10/10 absolutely love it.
Fit: I'm 5'10" at a stocky 210 pounds, not fat, but also not sporting a six-pack. The large fits perfectly. Loose enough to be super comfortable and tight enough to look trim.
Looks: A buddy and I are big fans of Club Ride, so we've got a bunch of different stuff, and I always think Club Ride gear looks better in person than in the photos. That said, colors look accurate in the pics, so it might be the material texture in person that makes it look better. Almost everyone I've worn it in front of has commented on how nice it looks.
Materials: You know it's good quality materials when you snag a single thread on an immovable metal protrusion with your body weight behind it, and that one thread puts up enough resistance to slow you down without fraying or snapping. Was able to just pull it back into place, thread the little excess back in, and it's good as new now. Yeah, it's well-made.
Comfort: Warmth, breathability, shape/design leave nothing lacking.
Overall: Just get it. You won't regret it.